RobertXGillis

RobertXGillis

25+ years of published Op/Ed columns, professional photography, my first book and more from the 28 known galaxies!

RobertXGillis
  • About Me
  • My professional photography
  • Nana – my first published book
  • Gillis Photo and Nana Videos
  • Site Map
  • Nativity

Star Trek: Let the Franchise rest in peace… Unless…

  • Star Trek

Kiek and Spock in Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home

by Robert Gillis

At the 2006 Comic Con, Paramount Pictures unveiled this teaser poster for Star Trek 11, due in 2008 and to be produced/directed by J.J. Abrams (Lost, Alias, etc).

Now, anyone who knows me will be surprised to hear this but I say it now — Star Trek is dead, let in rest in peace.

As one of the foremost Trekkers I know, the guy who can quote verbatim dialogue from the movies, the guy who has seen “Wrath of Khan” EASILY over 200 times, I say it’s time to let Star Trek rest.

Paramount clearly has no interest in the franchise. Judging by the ratings of the last two TV shows (Voyager, Enterprise) as well as the box-office take of the last few films, neither do the fans — or at least, that interest has severely dwindled. Enterprise, after all, was CANCELLED.

Trek has had its day and its glory days and died a sad death with the last film and the Enterprise finale (“These are the Voyages”) an episode that was indeed as an homage but was poorly written, and featured a grievous lack of finality for the crew and the completely unnecessary death of Trip Tucker. Despite the pleasure of seeing the always enjoyable Jonathan Frakes and Marina Sirtis, the finale was indeed appalling and undid a lot of the fourth season magic. The final death blow from Berman and Braga, thanks, guys. After a great fourth season with Manny Coto and the Reeves-Stevens at the helm — people who know and “get” Trek, we were treated to more drivel. And don’t even get me started on the “Alien Nazis” that Braga threw into the last ten seconds of a pretty excellent end to season three.

Now … I DO know what I am talking about … Consider:

In 1982 I saw “Wrath of Khan” and it blew me away. I was hooked and by summer’s end I’d seen all the old episodes (TOS) and Star Trek: The Motionless Picture (sorry, had to get that in). For years, I’ve loved the show, attended some conventions and enjoyed meeting the stars and shaking their hands. I watched the movies and episodes again and again. Some of the soundtracks – -particularly James Horner’s work on Trek’s II and III and some of Jerry Goldsmith’s work is beautiful and worth having. I became a Trekker.

I embraced Star Trek: The Next Generation (ST:TNG) and liked Voyager and Enterprise. (Never really took to DS9).

I’ve cherished the great movies (the even numbered movies and Search for Spock) and tolerated the bad (the odd movies except Search for Spock).

I have had lunch with George Takei and have met all of the original cast except DeForest Kelley. I have watched in awe, and stood and cheered, as Gene Roddenberry and Leonard Nimoy and William Shatner spoke in auditoriums. I have waited in line to see Trek films and followed Trek news on line.

I miss De Kelley and Jimmy Doohan. May they rest in peace.

Throughout it all, I have been a fan, using star dates in correspondence, writing Trek stories with friends, reading the books, watching and rewatching episodes and movies. I never dressed up as a character, certainly “had a life” and got that the show was — well, a TV show, but enjoyed it for solid entertainment and escapism.

I sum up the entire Star Trek franchise in the same manner producer Harve Bennet (Treks 2-5) once said of TOS: Trek was one third really good, one third OK, and one third ugh (Ugh meaning really bad). I feel that way about the franchise as a whole.

There were amazing stories over the last 40 years, and some of the writing in the shows had true moments of brilliance.

But it’s over. Despite a strong story idea, the last film, Star Trek: Nemesis, tanked at the box office ( I think many aspects of the film were great but there was way too much exposition, talky scenes, and a huge “been there, done that” feeling with Data’s brother android B4.)

The one exception seems to be the “new” episodes at Star Trek: New Voyages — fan produced, they are quite good and worth checking out HERE

I have always loved Star Trek. I always will. But it’s over. It had its glory days, its highs and its lows, and a few too many trips to the well. Will I see Trek 11? Sure, once, but only out of curiosity.

Star Trek is dead. Love live Star Trek.

Hailing frequencies closed.


However…

Acknowledging that I said “No more Star Trek movies” above, and to let the franchise die, I must add this thought:

This week it was announced that both William Shatner (Kirk) and Leonard Nimoy (Spock) were approached to be part of the new Trek film, and both expressed interest. This gives me some hope that the new movie could canonically right the greatest wrong in Star Trek: The meaningless death of James T. Kirk in Star Trek: Generations. Even Mr. Shatner must have thought (afterward) that Kirk’s demise was a bad idea, as his series of Trek novels resurrected Kirk and chronicles the captain’s continuing adventures in the 24th century with an aged Spock, McCoy, and Scotty, and the 24th century Trek crews.

In 1990, Harve Bennet, producer of Star Trek II-V, pitched a “Starfleet Academy” idea for Star Trek VI with a younger, new cast playing Kirk, Spock, and the other Original Series “Classic” crew members. Paramount reportedly balked that Shatner and Nimoy wouldn’t be in it, and Bennet wrote framing scenes at the beginning and end of the picture, where Admiral Kirk tells assembled cadets the story of how he met Spock all those years ago, and then the “younger cast” movie begins.

It looks like JJ Abrams is going in this direction as well. That’s great!

So here is my suggestion — since they’re bringing back Shatner’s Kirk, make it clear that Kirk is back from the dead by setting the framework portion of the story in the late 24th century, after the time of Kirk’s death on Veridian III (2371). Have Kirk in a post-Generations Starfleet uniform — the kind seen in the last three Trek films. Make a passing reference to the Enterprise E, or have a title card on the screen that established that the “older Kirk” part of the film takes place in, say, 2375 or 2379 (the “current” Next Generation time period). Anything to establish the date is AFTER Kirk’s death.

There’s no need to explain HOW Kirk came back from the dead– he’s known for cheating death after all. Leave that to the imagination of future story tellers.

And Shatner and Nimoy both look much older now, so the 24th century timeframe works better than pretending the framing portion of the film takes place, say, in the Classic Trek movie era.

It would be so simple — just a few lines of dialogue anywhere:

Use the lines that Spock used in Star Trek VI:

Officer: reacting to what seemed like a hopeless situation: “Then we’re dead.”
Kirk “I’ve been dead before.”

Or the line from Alien:

Officer: “I thought you were dead.”
Kirk: “I get that a lot.”

Or:

Spock: “Admiral … Jim … I am … pleased to see you again.”
Kirk, teasing: “Your quite logical relief that Starfleet had not lost a highly proficient captain, I suppose?”
Spock, almost a smile but not: “No. I have missed my captain, and my friend. It is … good to have you back.”

Just a few lines of dialogue, appropriate to the characters, and the fans are left with the knowledge that Kirk somehow escaped his fate on Veridian III and lives on, a hero, he and Spock reunited. Fans would be a lot more invested in the “Young Kirk,” knowing that he would continue to cheat death and thrive all those years later, rather than seeing the “new” young Kirk and knowing of his final, meaningless death on an unheard of planet. THAT might make sequels a little more likely as well.

The fans would love it.

What do you think, Mr. Abrams? Mr. Nimoy? Mr. Shatner?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Related Posts via Categories

  • My thoughts on Star Trek: Picard
  • Binge-Watching Star Trek Discovery during COVID-19 — a VERY entertaining Trek
  • Remembering Leonard Nimoy
  • Thoughts on the 2009 J.J. Abram Star Trek movie
  • Humor: The missing William Shatner scene in J.J. Abrams Star Trek 2009!
  • Thoughts on the J.J. Abrams Star Trek movie teaser trailer and what trekkers REALLY care about
  • Star Trek: Insurrection Review
  • Star Trek: Corel
  • NEW GENESIS: THE SEARCH FOR ROBERT FULLER
  • Review: Star Trek: First Contact
Spread the love
August 16, 2006 Robert Gillis 0

Post navigation

Nine planets no more: Earth’s planetary status revoked → ← Review: Jimmy Buffett at the Tweeter Center Mansfield, August 11, 2006

My Professional Photography

Buy My Book!

Go to Nana Book website

Follow Me!

  • Facebook

RobertXGillis.com Categories (Drop Down Menu)!

Category Cloudy Thingy!

A must read Avoiding Fraud Backstreets Boston Bruce Springsteen Catholic / Church Christmas CNN image Computers / Tech Current Events / News Commentary Current News Story Parody and Humor Dorchester Foxboro Foxboro Founders Day Foxboro Jaycees Foxboro Jaycees Haunted House Foxboro Reporter Image Halloween Holidays - Other Humor Life events, Gratitude and Giving and Little Miracles Mass Shootings Memorials Movies Music My fiction (80s/90s) Nana Book NASA Image New Hampshire News image from Web New Year Not The Best Pets Politics Scanned From Newspaper Microfilm Seniors September 11, 2001 Slow News Day Humor Sports Star Trek Superman Superman and Friends - Comic Book Humor and Parody Television Uncategorized Web / Email / Internet / Social Media

Robert Gillis Site Archives From the 28 Known Galaxies

Weekly Popular!

  • A dream come true, meeting Joanna Cameron, star of… (46)
  • Memories of an Intensive Care Nursery at Saint… (17)
  • Silver Age Comics: Spanking your super kids, a great… (13)
  • Memo: Cost-cutting measures during these tough… (12)
  • Foxboro Senior Center Christmas Faire (7)
  • An interview with Joanna Levesque, aka “JoJo” (6)
  • Review: Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band at… (6)
  • Grieving the Saint Kevin’s Property (5)
  • Silver Age Comics: Jimmy Olsen the Roughneck (and I… (5)
  • Remarkable Man, Remarkable Life, Remembering Gerry Rodman (5)
  • Retro-Review: A Christmas Carol (1999) starring… (5)
  • Thoughts and gratitude after the March 2018… (5)
  • End of Summer 2016: Thoughts on a variety of topics (5)
  • The Old Dorchester Neighborhood (4)
  • Letter I wrote to DC Comics when Superman died (4)
  • More Lucy Lane and Lois Lane Silver-Age Comics Sillyness! (4)
  • Cherishing the people around us – NOW (4)
  • More Silver Age Superboy antics: No matter where you… (4)
  • Review: SUPERMAN II: THE RICHARD DONNER CUT (4)
  • Foxboro’s Casino War: It’s Starting to… (4)
  • Practicing Skiing at the Old Mountain Home (4)
  • Silver Age Comic Books: Superman stops the… (4)
  • Review: BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN WITH THE SEEGER SESSIONS… (3)
  • More Silver-Age Lois Lane comic book madness! (3)
  • Retro-Review: A Christmas Carol (1938) starring… (2)
  • Popular posts by Top 10 plugin

Most Popular On This Site!

  • A dream come true, meeting Joanna Cameron, star of… (16,531)
  • An interview with Joanna Levesque, aka “JoJo” (6,122)
  • A letter to Mom on Christmas Day (3,641)
  • Memo: Cost-cutting measures during these tough… (3,234)
  • Silver Age Comics: Spanking your super kids, a great… (2,674)
  • Memories of an Intensive Care Nursery at Saint… (2,269)
  • Thoughts on visiting seven churches on Holy Thursday (1,702)
  • Father Steve Madden leaving Saint Mary’s… (1,612)
  • The National Shrine of Our Lady of La Salette in… (1,491)
  • Grieving the Saint Kevin’s Property (1,486)
  • The customer, most assuredly, is NOT always right: A… (1,378)
  • More Lucy Lane and Lois Lane Silver-Age Comics Sillyness! (1,193)
  • Silver-Age Comics fun: Going to the chapel, and… (1,027)
  • What was the Silver Age of comic books? Superman,… (1,015)
  • My professional photography (1,013)
  • Popular posts by Top 10 plugin

Copyright and Legal

All site content copyright © 2020 by Robert Gillis except where specifically noted. All rights reserved. THIS IS A PERSONAL WEBLOG (“BLOG”). THE OPINIONS AND COMMENTARY EXPRESSED HERE REPRESENT MY OWN AND ARE NOT THOSE OF MY EMPLOYERS (PAST, PRESENT NOR FUTURE).

About images:

I do my best to use my own photos to illustrate a post (and copyright to all my images remains with me), but sometimes I need to use an image from, say, a sports logo, a TV show or movie, or something I could not possibly get on my own, for example, an image of the international space station. I always credit the original owner (if they can be determined) but in ALL cases, whether credited or not, any images I didn’t photograph myself remain the property of the original copyright holders. This site does not imply any ownership of such images or materials, and such images are used here for commentary / illustrative / entertainment purposes only, under what is believed to be fair use guidelines, and absolutely no copyright infringement is intended.

Powered by WordPress | theme SG Double