RobertXGillis

RobertXGillis

25+ years of published Op/Ed columns, professional photography, my first book and more from the 28 known galaxies!

RobertXGillis
  • About Me
  • My professional photography
  • Nana – my first published book
  • Gillis Photo and Nana Videos
  • Site Map
  • Nativity

That’s Entertainment? The Wardrobe Malfunction at the Super Bowl

  • Current Events / News Commentary
  • Music
  • Not The Best
  • Sports

by Robert Gillis
Published in the Foxboro Reporter 2/2004

It’s taken me a little while to collect my thoughts about the alleged “wardrobe malfunction” incident during the Superbowl half-time show. But I finally figured out what needs to be done. It’s a baby step, but one in the right direction.

First of all, let’s dispense with the obvious rhetoric. Yeah, the line has been crossed. This is a sex-saturated culture. The act was reprehensible. Something must be done. It’s time for change!

Well, d’uh.

I’m not being flip, or in any mitigating the impact of what happened, but let’s remember that the Superbowl half-time show also featured performances by other artists that included barely-clad women and a lot of crotch grabbing. Many of the ads were for erectile dysfunction, and most other Superbowl ads were pretty lowbrow, including fart jokes, bathroom humor, dogs biting a guy’s nether regions, and a monkey putting the move on a model. But all we hear about is the infamous breast-baring moment.

Why is that? It’s because in a halftime show full of seductive firecrackers, Jackson and Timberlake set off a sexual nuke. And suddenly, everyone finally noticed just how bad things have gotten, just how indecent things have become.

Yes, a line was crossed. Big time. The actions of Janet Jackson and Justin Timberlake were reprehensible, stupid, wholly inappropriate, and crass. That it was an intentional stunt – despite the idiotic claim of “wardrobe malfunction” – makes it all the more wrong. That Jackson and Timberlake knew that over 90 million people – including millions of children – would witness it — is deplorable.

MTV personality Carson Daly was quoted as saying, “This particular event might be, for the moment, the straw that broke the camel’s back on the patience of the audience. Tolerance of this sort of sexual imagery may have reached its peak.”

FCC Commissioner Michael Copps commented, “The Jackson case could have a “galvanizing effect” on the move to toughen standards … at the very least, he said, it punctures the argument of people who say that those who are bothered by things on TV just shouldn’t watch. ”

Maybe. But honestly, I doubt it. Was the halftime show inappropriate for the millions of small children watching? Absolutely! But so are half the shows on prime time TV. We’ve seen worse, haven’t we? This is a sex-saturated culture where few things surprise us anymore. Sleaze sells. Sex sells.

It’s not right, it’s not moral, but there it is, in every magazine, in every video, on every channel. As a culture, we obviously like it, because we buy the products and patronize the companies. We buy the music, the movies, watch the shows and judging by the demand, we want more.

Generational attitudes may change, standards will vary, but the envelope will always be pushed – new limits of “just how much can we get away with” will always be tested.

I am not defending it.

I am not condoning it.

I am not excusing it.

But this is our reality in 21st century America.

It’s very sad.

So what should we do? Despite calls for immediate FCC investigations, fining the networks and opening new debates about decency and morality, it is the two “performers” who should be held responsible. That’s where a positive change can begin.

Don’t fine Timberlake and Jackson – they have so much money, financial penalties are meaningless. Threaten all the boycotts you want, but kids will still buy their CDs and attend the concerts. Let’s do the one thing that might make a difference: Require an apology, and make sure it is directed at the ones who most need to hear it: The kids.

Forget prepared press statements. At their own expense – not their management or record company – Timberlake and Jackson should take out full page ads in EVERY teen magazine – YM, Teen Beat, Teen People, and all the others – and apologize. In their own words, they need to admit that their actions were thoughtless, crass, and wrong, and explain WHY they were wrong.

Forget CNN and Larry King. The apologies have to be made when the kids are reading and watching. The apologies should be broadcast on MTV and VH-1.

On the liner notes of both of their next CDs, let’s see the same apology. Kids read every word of those liner notes. Maybe while Timberlake is thanking God and his family on his next CD, he can add how sorry he is for being such a pig at the Superbowl. Perhaps he can explain that he is not a role model and no one should ever do what he did, and that people can actually go to jail for doing what he did.

Maybe Jackson’s apology can help explain why she orchestrated the stunt, and why she’s sorry for it. Maybe Jackson can explain why she exercised such a galactic lack of common sense and did something so obscene at the same time her brother is in court fighting sex abuse charges.

Maybe these alleged role models could teach a little – just a little – personal integrity and responsibility to their millions of fans. Maybe they can help set things in the right direction.

Parents and teachers and can lecture all they want, but when the kids hear apologies and explanations from these “role models” themselves, maybe they’ll understand. Maybe they’ll listen. I really hope so. Because if this level of personal responsibility and apology isn’t forthcoming from Timberlake and Jackson, then what happened at the Superbowl is only the beginning.


Update 2015: While I cannot possibly condone ripping off a woman’s top during a concert performance (you can go to jail for that in most some states!) I think I came across wait too hard on both JT and Janet. I’ve always liked Janet Jackson and have come to really respect JT as an actor and performer. Regardless of their revisionist history and the concept of “wardrobe malfunction” I think it what they did was either spur of the moment or a publicity stunt.

Considering that most Super Bowl commercials feature guys getting kicked in the balls, or sell medicines for erectile dysfunction, or feature sexists ads, usually in some way demeaning to men or women, a split second breast flash on live TV before the live feed was cut doesn’t mean much compared to the saturation of violence and sex out there, even during the game. This incident was HARDLY a watershed moment for ANYTHING except more hype for months before things went back to the way they always were.

So to clarify, I’d write this one differently today. Ripping off someone’s clothes (especially on live TV) is not brilliant, but I was waayyy too hard on JT and Janet — and given the venue they were playing, and the commercials during the game, their action almost pales by comparison. Like I said, not one of my best.  And I’d still pay money to see either of them in concert!

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Related Posts via Categories

  • We Are All Patriots — Thank you Pats for an amazing 2015-2016 season!
  • Boston Red Sox prove we are BOSTON STRONG with World Series win at Fenway
  • Reevaluating what makes a hero and a role model
  • Unruly Boston sports fans are a disgrace
  • Clothes To The Dark Side
  • Proud sponsors are nothing to be proud of
  • Black Lives Matter
  • America 2020: Protests, Violence, Racism — Divided We Fall
  • The Church still stands: Remembering the promise of Easter Sunday after the Notre Dame Cathedral fire
  • Twenty-Five takeaways from Sunday’s Patriots Super Bowl sendoff rally, Sunday January 28, 2019
Spread the love
February 1, 2004 Robert Gillis 0

Post navigation

The Foxboro Jaycees are very active — and would love to meet you! → ← New England Patriots make us proud during winter of our discontent

My Professional Photography

Buy My Book!

Go to Nana Book website

Follow Me!

  • Facebook

RobertXGillis.com Categories (Drop Down Menu)!

Category Cloudy Thingy!

A must read Avoiding Fraud Backstreets Boston Bruce Springsteen Catholic / Church Christmas CNN image Computers / Tech Current Events / News Commentary Current News Story Parody and Humor Dorchester Foxboro Foxboro Founders Day Foxboro Jaycees Foxboro Jaycees Haunted House Foxboro Reporter Image Halloween Holidays - Other Humor Life events, Gratitude and Giving and Little Miracles Mass Shootings Memorials Movies Music My fiction (80s/90s) Nana Book NASA Image New Hampshire News image from Web New Year Not The Best Pets Politics Scanned From Newspaper Microfilm Seniors September 11, 2001 Slow News Day Humor Sports Star Trek Superman Superman and Friends - Comic Book Humor and Parody Television Uncategorized Web / Email / Internet / Social Media

Robert Gillis Site Archives From the 28 Known Galaxies

Weekly Popular!

  • A dream come true, meeting Joanna Cameron, star of… (41)
  • Memories of an Intensive Care Nursery at Saint… (10)
  • Memo: Cost-cutting measures during these tough… (9)
  • Yes Virginia, there is a Santa Claus, you betcha! (8)
  • A loss too deep for words: Remembering Lorraine and… (8)
  • More Silver-Age Lois Lane comic book madness! (5)
  • Silver Age Comics: Spanking your super kids, a great… (5)
  • Memories of Halloween (5)
  • Grieving the Saint Kevin’s Property (5)
  • Play the TV News Snow Game! (Global Warming… (5)
  • An historical quest fulfilled: Finding the Willey… (4)
  • Silver Age Comic Books: Superman stops the… (4)
  • What was the Silver Age of comic books? Superman,… (4)
  • The Weakest Link (3)
  • Katy Perry’s “Firework:” A message every teen needs to hear (3)
  • Retro-Review: A Christmas Carol (1938) starring… (3)
  • Dinner with Mom brings back Memories of Christmas Past (3)
  • An interview with Joanna Levesque, aka “JoJo” (3)
  • Bruce Springsteen at Fenway Park September 6 and 7, 2003 (3)
  • Review: SUPERMAN II: THE RICHARD DONNER CUT (3)
  • Letter I wrote to DC Comics when Superman died (2)
  • Almost completed: The WMJX 106.7 “Magic of… (2)
  • The National Shrine of Our Lady of La Salette in… (2)
  • Silver Age Superman Comics Review: The irresistible… (2)
  • The customer, most assuredly, is NOT always right: A… (2)
  • Popular posts by Top 10 plugin

Most Popular On This Site!

  • A dream come true, meeting Joanna Cameron, star of… (16,744)
  • An interview with Joanna Levesque, aka “JoJo” (6,155)
  • A letter to Mom on Christmas Day (3,656)
  • Memo: Cost-cutting measures during these tough… (3,309)
  • Silver Age Comics: Spanking your super kids, a great… (2,728)
  • Memories of an Intensive Care Nursery at Saint… (2,334)
  • Thoughts on visiting seven churches on Holy Thursday (1,716)
  • Father Steve Madden leaving Saint Mary’s… (1,625)
  • Grieving the Saint Kevin’s Property (1,536)
  • The National Shrine of Our Lady of La Salette in… (1,514)
  • The customer, most assuredly, is NOT always right: A… (1,399)
  • More Lucy Lane and Lois Lane Silver-Age Comics Sillyness! (1,215)
  • Katy Perry’s “Firework:” A message every teen needs to hear (1,045)
  • Silver-Age Comics fun: Going to the chapel, and… (1,042)
  • What was the Silver Age of comic books? Superman,… (1,039)
  • Popular posts by Top 10 plugin

Copyright and Legal

All site content copyright © 2020 by Robert Gillis except where specifically noted. All rights reserved. THIS IS A PERSONAL WEBLOG (“BLOG”). THE OPINIONS AND COMMENTARY EXPRESSED HERE REPRESENT MY OWN AND ARE NOT THOSE OF MY EMPLOYERS (PAST, PRESENT NOR FUTURE).

About images:

I do my best to use my own photos to illustrate a post (and copyright to all my images remains with me), but sometimes I need to use an image from, say, a sports logo, a TV show or movie, or something I could not possibly get on my own, for example, an image of the international space station. I always credit the original owner (if they can be determined) but in ALL cases, whether credited or not, any images I didn’t photograph myself remain the property of the original copyright holders. This site does not imply any ownership of such images or materials, and such images are used here for commentary / illustrative / entertainment purposes only, under what is believed to be fair use guidelines, and absolutely no copyright infringement is intended.

Powered by WordPress | theme SG Double